India Cut Maternal Mortality. So Why Are Dalit and Adivasi Women Still Dying Disproportionately?

When a woman has reason to expect disrespect at the hospital door, hesitation is not ignorance. It is experience.
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.File Photo- x@Krishnamurthy
Published on: 

— ✍️ Dr. Bhimi Daimari

India is losing far fewer mothers than it did a generation ago. The Sample Registration System (SRS) puts the national maternal mortality ratio (MMR) at 88 deaths per 100,000 live births for 2021–23, down from 93 in 2019–21 and 130 in 2014–16. United Nations estimates tell the same story over a longer span: from 362 in 2000 to 80 in 2023. This is a real achievement, and it belongs to the ASHAs, nurses, midwives and doctors who made it happen.

Yet the same UN report estimates that about 19,000 Indian women still died of pregnancy-related causes in 2023 — roughly 52 every day. As an obstetrician, I cannot read that number only as progress. I have to ask who these women are. And the evidence we have points, again and again, to the same answer: they are disproportionately Dalit, Adivasi and poor.

The average hides the woman

Here is the first problem. The SRS bulletins that give us our headline MMR report it by State and region, not by caste or tribe. We do not routinely publish how many Scheduled Caste (SC) or Scheduled Tribe (ST) mothers die. What is not counted is easily ignored.

So we have to read the risks that lead to death, and there the pattern is clear. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5, 2019–21), 88.6 per cent of births in India now take place in a health facility. Figures the Union Health Ministry placed before the Rajya Sabha in December 2023 show the share is 87.3 per cent for SC women and 82.3 per cent for ST women. Put differently, nearly one in five Adivasi mothers still gives birth without the safety net of a facility. The gap used to be wider: Oxfam India's 2021 inequality report found institutional births among ST households in 2015–16 were 15 per cent below those in the general category.

Antenatal care tells a harsher story. A 2025 analysis in BMC Women's Health found that only 26.9 per cent of Scheduled Caste mothers received full antenatal care in NFHS-5, up from 20.7 per cent five years earlier. In Bihar and Uttar Pradesh the figure was about one in ten; in Kerala, about eight in ten. Within the same community, mothers from poorer households were less than half as likely to receive full care as those from richer ones. Caste, class and geography stack on top of each other.

Then there is anaemia, which makes bleeding after childbirth - a leading cause of maternal death - far more dangerous. A Harvard analysis of NFHS-5 data found 64.6 per cent of ST women aged 15–49 were anaemic, against 56.2 per cent of other women; among pregnant women the figures were 59.3 and 51.3 per cent. Researchers writing in the Journal of Biosocial Science concluded that SC and ST women carry a disproportionate share of India's anaemia burden, worst where caste meets poverty and rural residence.

The inequality does not end with childbirth. A 2018 UN Women report noted that Dalit women in India die, on average, 14.6 years younger than women from higher castes.

A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
Study Reveals 61% of Pregnant Women in Southern Rajasthan Lack Ambulance Access for Childbirth

Three delays, sharpened by caste

Public health uses a simple framework to explain why mothers die: the "three delays". A delay in deciding to seek care. A delay in reaching it. A delay in receiving proper care once there. Each is too often described as a woman's or a family's failing. Seen through caste, each is structural.

Deciding. A family weighs lost wages, the cost of travel and how they expect to be treated. A systematic review of caste and health discrimination in South Asia, published in the Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health in 2021, identified social stigma, poverty and poor access as recurring barriers, and found Dalit women used antenatal care far less than higher-caste women. When a woman has reason to expect disrespect at the hospital door, hesitation is not ignorance. It is experience.

Reaching. Adivasi hamlets and Dalit settlements are frequently the furthest from a functioning facility, across forest, hills, rivers and bad roads. An ambulance that arrives hours late, or transport that must be paid for in cash, turns a treatable complication into a fatal one.

Receiving. A woman may arrive in time and still find no one who can operate or transfuse blood. The government's own Rural Health Statistics 2021–22 recorded a 79.5 per cent shortfall of specialists at community health centres, including a 74.2 per cent shortfall of obstetricians and gynaecologists. These are the very centres that marginalised rural families depend on. Private care, the usual escape from a failing public system, is the option they can least afford.

None of this is about what mothers did wrong. It is about what was never put within their reach.

Nutrition and anaemia programmes need to reach adolescent girls and pregnant women in the hamlets where rates are highest, and be monitored there.
Nutrition and anaemia programmes need to reach adolescent girls and pregnant women in the hamlets where rates are highest, and be monitored there.Symbolic Image

What would actually help

Count every mother. Maternal deaths, and maternal death reviews, should be reported by caste and tribe, district by district. We cannot close a gap we refuse to measure.

Put the best-staffed facilities where the risk is highest. Specialists, blood storage, functioning operating theatres and reliable referral transport must be prioritised in tribal and SC-dense districts, not posted there last.

Make respectful maternity care enforceable. Every woman is owed dignity, consent and attention in the labour room. Discrimination by caste should carry consequences, with grievance systems that a labourer's family can actually use.

Invest in health workers from the community. ASHAs and midwives drawn from Dalit and Adivasi communities — fairly paid and supported — build trust that no awareness campaign can.

Treat anaemia as an emergency of justice. Nutrition and anaemia programmes need to reach adolescent girls and pregnant women in the hamlets where rates are highest, and be monitored there.

Remove the cost of the journey. Free, dependable transport and timely maternity entitlements shorten the first two delays more than any lecture on "health-seeking behaviour".

The measure of our progress

India has shown that maternal deaths are not fate; they fall when a country decides they should. The next stage of that progress will not be found in the national average. It will be found in whether a mother in an Adivasi hamlet or a Dalit basti has the same chance of coming home with her baby as a mother in a city apartment.

A mother's survival should not depend on her caste, or on her village. We already know how to make that true. What remains is to decide that every mother counts and then to count her.

- Dr. Bhimi Daimari, MBBS, MS (Obstetrics & Gynaecology), is an obstetrician-gynaecologist based in Hojai, Assam, and the medical reviewer at abortion-riyadh.com.

A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
How a 9-Month Pregnant Woman is Using Social Media to Expose Madhya Pradesh's Infrastructure Failures
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
Are Rajasthan’s Family Welfare Schemes Failing? 55-YO Udaipur Woman Gives Birth to 17th Child, Misleads Hospital About Fourth Pregnancy
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
What the NCRB 2024 Data Says About the Lives of Dalit Women
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
Labour Without Security, Lives Without Dignity: Public Hearing Chronicles Structural Exploitation of Dalit Women Workers in Delhi
A pregnant woman is carried in a harness in Andhra Pradesh — for many Adivasi and Dalit families, reaching a health facility is the second of the 'three delays'.
Dalit History Month | 'They Never Wanted This Job': How 'Warsa Hakka' Forces Women into Safai Karamcharis in Maharashtra

You can also join our WhatsApp group to get premium and selected news of The Mooknayak on WhatsApp. Click here to join the WhatsApp group.

Subscribe The Mooknayak

'The Mooknayak' practices democratic journalism. It is a media platform committed to the Constitution, democracy, and social justice. If you also want 'The Mooknayak' to always raise the voices of the marginalized and show the pain of the voiceless, please subscribe.

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE US