Eight kilometres from Class 9

In western UP, 200 girls made the daily trek home from a so-called residential school. Their journey home is a stark illustration of what the impressive enrolment figures so conveniently ignore: who actually stays in school and who is left behind at the last bell.
Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.
Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.Symbolic Image
Published on: 

— ✍️Aastha Kanwar Gautam

Kajal could recite her options for Class 9 by heart. The government school in Marhara (eight km from her village of Piwari in Etah) was the only viable option. Her dad farmed the land, and private school fees were just out of reach. When Amar Ujala spoke to her in December 2021, she was still in Class 8 and fully expecting it to be her last year in school.

On 31 October 2026, the UP government announced the enrolment of over 88,000 girls in its Kasturba Gandhi residential schools. The scheme is aimed at providing education as well as a home to girls from the most disadvantaged sections of society, including Dalit girls. In Etah, though, a girl could be on the hostel register and still have to be given a ride home every afternoon.

Etah's Kasturba school in the Sakit block was promised a shiny new hostel and teaching block in 2020. Two hundred girls were admitted by December 2020, but the buildings were still a mirage. By the next July, the Class 9 girls were being taught in the improvised old structure while the new structure sat there with no furniture and no working kitchen. The upshot was that all 200 girls who were supposed to be residents were still going to and from school every day. The follow-up report gives the state of the building and answers the question of what happened to it. It does not say how many of the girls making that daily journey in 2022 actually stayed long enough to sleep in it.

The Right to Education Act guarantees every child aged 6 to 14 a free, compulsory education in a neighbourhood school. It stops at Class 8, though. According to the Union Education Ministry's UDISE+ data, around 78% of girls in UP go from Class 8 to 9. The 2024 Annual Status of Education Report does, however, highlight the cracks: among rural 15-16 year olds, a ride to school remains out of reach for many.

In Harevli (a village in the Bijnor district), the only government school was at the Class 8 level by 2023. The secondary schools were in Nangal and Mandawali. Researchers Daya Susan Thomas and Madhura Swaminathan found that only one of the private schools serving Harevli operated a minibus. All the children in the Harevli village survey who attended that school were from Tyagi households.

November was the sugarcane harvest season. The researchers found children missing 15 days or more of school, working the fields alongside their families. For Jatava households, it was the norm for both boys and girls aged 8-15 to be away from school for that length of time. A girl could be away for two weeks cutting cane and still have her name on the school roll.

The researchers found children missing 15 days or more of school, working the fields alongside their families.
The researchers found children missing 15 days or more of school, working the fields alongside their families. Symbolic image

"My mother wanted me to go to school," a girl from the Teli community in Madhukar, Rampur district, told education researcher Anita Nuna. In 2009, her mother helped her get into Class 9 at a private inter college three km away. She left after six months because the older men in the family did not want her to continue. Another girl in Madhukar (Ruksana) told Nuna that her mother was unwell and needed her at home. Her mother also felt that a girl should be taught to run a household (she would eventually marry into one). Ruksana left after Class 8. Both stories were published by Nuna in 2013. "Family decision" barely conveys the anguish of a mother who is determined to keep her daughter in school and who ends up losing her.

The price of getting home

July 2026 saw a 13-year-old girl in Jalesar (where I run a private school) stop coming to school. Her family informed the police that a man had threatened her on her way home on the 16th of July. She stayed at home in silence for a while and only eventually told her family why. A case was registered by the police (Amar Ujala). What a girl in that situation needs is a teacher who will listen behind closed doors and someone who will just ask the most fundamental question of all: "How are you getting home tomorrow?"

Teachers could be the cartographers of safety. In Muzaffarnagar in 2025, Sangeeta, a government school teacher, told Hindustan that her e-rickshaw had dropped her five km short of her school in Dadupur. Upendra Baliyan, head teacher in Mukandpur, was keen on better transport for staff, but even more so on better transport so that children from the surrounding villages could actually get to his school.

Samagra Shiksha provides a bit of a bureaucratic lifeline to some of these journeys. In areas designated for transport, secondary school students travelling more than 5 km can qualify for up to Rs 6,000 a year. Kajal's 8 km was sufficient. Was Piwari on the map, though? If so, where exactly was she to catch the bus from Marhara?

Etah's education officers can start with the Class 8 girls in Piwari this year. Ask each one where she intends to go next and how she'll get home when the final bell rings. Six weeks into term, you can go to the receiving schools and check the registers. Publish the routes and fares and the number of girls still in each block. No need to name names, just the numbers.

Amar Ujala's 2021 report also had Preeti from Samaspur. She completed Class 8 at the Marhara residential school in 2019 and intended to stay on. With no Class 9, her schooling came to an end there. By June 2025, district coordinator Sanjay Mishra had told Hindustan that the upgrades were finally getting underway. If only they'd been done earlier, Preeti might have made it to Class 12.

- Aastha Kanwar Gautam is the owner and director of Shemford Futuristic School in Jalesar, Etah. This analysis draws on public records, published interviews and village research.

Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.
India Cut Maternal Mortality. So Why Are Dalit and Adivasi Women Still Dying Disproportionately?
Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.
How a Tribal Teacher from Rajasthan, Suspended Over 'Sindoor-Mangalsutra' Controversy, Urges Girls to Prioritize Education Over Conservative Practices
Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.
How Telangana Government’s Generosity Will Enable a Tribal Girl’s IIT Patna Education
Despite impressive enrolment figures, girls in western Uttar Pradesh are quietly pushed out of school after Class 8 by long, unsafe commutes, unfinished residential facilities, family pressure, and a lack of functioning transport support.
Opposition, NSUI Hit Hard on Rajasthan Govt After Girl Students Protest Teacher’s Alleged Molestation in Kekri School

You can also join our WhatsApp group to get premium and selected news of The Mooknayak on WhatsApp. Click here to join the WhatsApp group.

Subscribe The Mooknayak

'The Mooknayak' practices democratic journalism. It is a media platform committed to the Constitution, democracy, and social justice. If you also want 'The Mooknayak' to always raise the voices of the marginalized and show the pain of the voiceless, please subscribe.

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE US