Constitutional Case Builds for Reservation in Chartered Accountancy: Ten Reasons Why ICAI Must Act

In this piece, senior IRS officer Nethrapal marshals constitutional provisions, landmark Supreme Court judgments, statutory analysis, and comparative practices across professions to build a structured case for reservation in the Chartered Accountancy course.
One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.
One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.AI image
Published on: 

New Delhi: The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) is facing growing scrutiny over its continued refusal to implement reservation in the CA course, with constitutional experts and commentators arguing that the Institute's position is legally untenable and out of step with parallel professions.

In a detailed analysis, Ambedkarite thinker and senior IRS officer Nethrapal argues that ICAI's resistance to affirmative action contradicts the Constitution, the Institute's own statutory framework, and its own admissions in court. The analysis comes amid broader debate about inclusivity in professional education and follows practices already established in law and medicine.

The fundamental inconsistency highlighted is stark: an SC or ST candidate sitting the All India Bar Examination needs 40% to qualify, while a general candidate needs 45%. In postgraduate medicine, seats are reserved and qualifying thresholds are lower for reserved categories. At ICAI, however, there is no reservation, no relaxed pass mark, and not even a caste-based fee concession.

ICAI's defenders claim the CA exam is a pure test of merit, open to all. But this claim, the analysis argues, does not hold up against the Constitution, ICAI's own statute, or the Institute's own statements in court.

Ten Reasons ICAI Must Act

1. ICAI Says It Is an Educational Institution

When its income-tax exemption was at stake, ICAI argued that education was its primary object and that regulating the profession was ancillary to it. The Delhi High Court upheld its charitable status in DGIT (Exemptions) v. ICAI, (2012) 347 ITR 86 (Del). In 2016, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal again called it an educational institution. The argument is that an institution that takes the tax benefits of being an educational body should also accept the constitutional duties that come with it.

2. The Constitution Already Allows Reservation

Article 15(5) lets the State make special provision for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and socially and educationally backward classes in admission to educational institutions, "including private educational institutions, whether aided or unaided by the State." It expressly overrides the freedom of profession under Article 19(1)(g), which autonomous bodies usually rely on. In Pramati Educational & Cultural Trust v. Union of India (2014), a Constitution Bench upheld the clause even for private unaided institutions. ICAI's financial independence does not take it outside Article 15(5).

3. ICAI Is Not a Private Club

The Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 gives the Central Government real control over ICAI. It nominates up to eight members of the Council under Section 9(2)(b). It makes rules under Section 29A. It can direct the Council to make or amend regulations, and make them itself if the Council refuses (Section 30A). It can also issue binding directions and dissolve the Council for persistent default (Section 30C). That is control written into the statute, not mere regulatory oversight. In 2023, the Karnataka High Court treated ICAI as an authority under Article 12. If ICAI is "State" for writ purposes, Articles 14, 15 and 16 bind it too.

4. ICAI Controls Entry to a State-Created Monopoly

Only a chartered accountant may be appointed auditor of a company under Section 141 of the Companies Act, 2013, or furnish a tax audit report under the Income-tax Act. These are public functions that Parliament has reserved for ICAI's members. A body that decides who may perform them is exercising public power, and public power must follow the Constitution's equality guarantees.

5. The Bar Council Already Does It

The Bar Council of India is a statutory regulator, and the All India Bar Examination is a licensing test for practice, much like the CA exam. Its qualifying mark is 45% for general and OBC candidates and 40% for SC, ST and persons with disabilities. Nobody claims this has weakened the Bar. The argument is that if lawyers can be licensed on this basis, it is hard to see why chartered accountants cannot.

6. Medicine Already Does It

Postgraduate medical education reserves seats for SC, ST, OBC and EWS candidates and allows lower qualifying thresholds for reserved categories. The Supreme Court has upheld both. A specialist doctor's competence matters at least as much to the public as an auditor's. If "standards" do not rule out reservation in medicine, they cannot rule it out in accountancy.

7. "CA Is a Skill, Not a Degree" Has Already Lost in Court

The argument most often heard is that ICAI only certifies a high-order skill, and certification has no place for reservation. The same argument was made against OBC and EWS reservation in postgraduate medicine: that specialist training is too skilled for quotas. In Neil Aurelio Nunes v. Union of India (2022), the Supreme Court rejected it. It held that high scores in an examination are not a proxy for merit, and that merit must be understood in its social context. An open competitive examination secures only formal equality. Unequal access to coaching, resources and networks decides who scores well.

8. Open Entry Is Not Equal Opportunity

ICAI's defenders say anyone can register, so no one is excluded. But being allowed to attempt is not the same as having a fair chance to succeed. The CA route has three levels of examination with famously low pass rates, which reward years of paid coaching. Articleship places are often found through family and community networks, and stipends are modest. Each stage favours those who started ahead. Relaxing a pass mark to correct this is well established in law: in State of M.P. v. Nivedita Jain (1981), the Supreme Court upheld relaxed qualifying marks for SC and ST candidates under Article 15(4).

9. Parliament Has Given ICAI a Development Mandate

In 2022, Parliament amended the long title of the Chartered Accountants Act to read: "An Act to make provision for the regulation and development of the profession of Chartered Accountants." The words "and development" were a deliberate addition. A profession that keeps drawing from the same narrow social base is not being developed. Making the profession more inclusive is now part of ICAI's statutory purpose.

10. ICAI Is Out of Step with Its Own Ministry

The Institute of Company Secretaries of India, under the same Ministry of Corporate Affairs, charges SC and ST students half the registration and examination fees. The Indian Institute of Corporate Affairs reserves seats in its Graduate Insolvency Programme on the full constitutional pattern. ICAI's fee concessions are tied only to region and disability, and it publishes no category-wise data on who registers, passes or qualifies. In July 2004, the then Ministry of Company Affairs directed ICAI to reserve 22.5% of its staff posts for SCs and STs. More than two decades later, there is no public evidence that this directive has been implemented.

The Modest Ask

The analysis emphasizes that no constitutional amendment is needed. ICAI's Council can act under Section 30 of the Chartered Accountants Act. If it will not, the Central Government can direct it under Section 30A and, if the Council still refuses, make the regulations itself.

A fair package, the analysis suggests, would include:

  • Annual publication of category-wise data on registration, results, articleship and membership.

  • Fee concessions for SC, ST and EWS students, on the ICSI model.

  • A modest relaxation in qualifying marks for SC, ST, OBC (non-creamy layer) and EWS candidates, on the Bar Council model, reviewed every five years.

  • Full implementation of the 2004 staff-reservation directive.

The syllabus, the examination and the certificate would stay exactly the same. What changes, the analysis concludes, is that India's accounting profession would finally follow the same Constitution as its lawyers and doctors.

With the legal and constitutional ground increasingly well-mapped, the pressure on ICAI to act appears to be mounting. The Institute's own admissions in tax litigation, its statutory character as a body under significant government control, and the precedent set by parallel professional regulators all point in one direction. The question, as the analysis frames it, is not whether reservation is constitutionally permissible in chartered accountancy, it clearly is, but whether ICAI can continue to justify its exceptionalism in the face of mounting evidence that the current system perpetuates inequality rather than merit.

As the debate unfolds, all eyes will be on whether ICAI's Council takes the initiative under Section 30 or whether the Central Government will be compelled to exercise its powers under Section 30A to bring the Institute in line with the constitutional framework that governs India's other professional education bodies.

One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.
The Case Against NEET: 10 Reasons Why India Must Rethink National Medical Admissions
One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.
"10 reasons Why UGC Equity Regulations 2026 is Against SC, ST, and OBCs More than the General Category": Nethrapal
One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.
10 Reasons Why Negative Cutoff in PG NEET is a Myth
One absent step separates thousands of aspirants from the CA emblem, even as lawyers and doctors ascend an unbroken ladder alongside. The Constitution permits reservation in professional education, ICAI alone has left the rung out.
"Not a Single Extra Day!" – BANAE Lists 10 Reasons Why IIM Bangalore Director Doesn’t Deserve Extension, Cites Caste Discrimination & Unplaced Students

You can also join our WhatsApp group to get premium and selected news of The Mooknayak on WhatsApp. Click here to join the WhatsApp group.

Subscribe The Mooknayak

'The Mooknayak' practices democratic journalism. It is a media platform committed to the Constitution, democracy, and social justice. If you also want 'The Mooknayak' to always raise the voices of the marginalized and show the pain of the voiceless, please subscribe.

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE US