Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and Dr. Ambedkar: Exploring Common Grounds and Differing Views

Today, as the entire country celebrates the birthday of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel as "National Unity Day," it would be fascinating to explore the areas in which Dr. Ambedkar and Sardar Patel found unanimity and those matters where they held disagreements.
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and Dr. Ambedkar
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and Dr. Ambedkar

Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, also known as the "Iron Man of India", was the first Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister of India after independence. Patel, born on 31 October 1875 in the Nadiad district of Gujarat state, was a prominent figure in the Government of India and also a member of the Constituent Assembly. Today, on 31st October, the whole country is celebrating his birthday as National Unity Day.

The coming generations will always remember the contributions of Sardar Patel and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar in giving shape to the structure of the disorganized country after independence in 1947. However, there were agreements and disagreements between the two great men on many issues that made India look new. As citizens of an "Independent Country", much of what we have today goes to the credit of these two great men.

In today's article, we will know on which issues there were similarities and differences in views between Sardar Patel and Ambedkar. Because it would be interesting for us to know on what matters there were disagreements and agreements between the two great men who made important contributions to the interest of the country, to citizens' rights, equality, and education.

Sardar Patel and B.R. Ambedkar were two prominent leaders in post-independence India who played significant roles in shaping the country's political and social landscape. While they had differences in their political ideologies and priorities, there were also some similarities in their ideas and approaches, particularly in the context of nation-building and social justice. 

Here are some of the common ideas and similarities between Sardar Patel and Ambedkar:

1. Commitment to a Unified India

Both Patel and Ambedkar were committed to the idea of a united and integrated India. Sardar Patel played a crucial role in the integration of princely states into the newly independent India, ensuring territorial unity. Ambedkar also supported the idea of a united India and was a key architect of the Indian Constitution, which provided a federal structure while maintaining the unity of the nation.

2. Secularism

Both leaders advocated for a secular India, where people of all religions would have equal rights and opportunities. They believed in a society where religious differences would not be a source of discrimination or conflict.

3. Social Justice

B.R. Ambedkar was a champion of social justice and the rights of the oppressed and marginalized communities, particularly the Dalits (formerly known as Untouchables). Sardar Patel, too, recognized the need for upliftment and social justice for backward and tribal communities and worked towards their integration and development within the mainstream society.

4. Constitutional Framework

Ambedkar and Patel had a hand in shaping India's constitutional framework. Ambedkar, as the Chairman of the Drafting Committee, played a pivotal role in drafting the Indian Constitution, which enshrined fundamental rights and social justice principles. Sardar Patel, as the Deputy Prime Minister, worked to establish a strong and centralized government within the federal system.

5. Opposition to Communalism

Both leaders opposed communalism and religious fundamentalism. Sardar Patel worked to contain and manage communal tensions, particularly during the partition of India, and advocated for the peaceful coexistence of different religious communities. Ambedkar, while a strong advocate for the rights of the Dalits, also spoke out against religious orthodoxy and the caste system.

6. Emphasis on Education

Both leaders recognized the importance of education in empowering individuals and communities. Sardar Patel supported the expansion of educational institutions, while Ambedkar worked to promote education among the Dalits and other marginalized groups.

It's important to note that while there were these similarities in their ideas and approaches, there were also significant differences in their political philosophies and priorities. Sardar Patel was a key figure in the Indian National Congress and was closely associated with the Congress's approach to nation-building, while Ambedkar, as an independent political leader and the leader of the Scheduled Castes Federation, had a more specific focus on the rights and welfare of the Dalit community. Despite these differences, both leaders left a lasting impact on the development of modern India.

On which matters were there disagreements between Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and Dr. Ambedkar

Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, despite some commonalities in their vision for post-independence India, had significant disagreements and differences on several important matters. 

Some of the key areas of disagreement between them include:

1. Integration of Princely States

One of the major areas of disagreement between Patel and Ambedkar was related to the integration of princely states into the newly independent India. Sardar Patel, as the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Home Affairs, played a crucial role in persuading and sometimes coercing the princely states to accede to the Indian Union. Patel's approach was to use a combination of diplomacy, negotiation, and force if necessary to ensure the territorial integrity of India. Ambedkar, on the other hand, was concerned about the rights of the Dalits in the princely states. He believed that the accession process should consider the welfare and rights of marginalized communities in these states. Their differing perspectives sometimes led to tensions between them.

2. Reservation Policy

Another notable disagreement was regarding the reservation policy for Scheduled Castes (Dalits) and Scheduled Tribes. Ambedkar was a strong advocate for reserved seats in legislative bodies and government jobs to uplift the Dalits, as he believed this was crucial for their social and economic empowerment. Sardar Patel, while not opposing reservations, had a more cautious approach. He was concerned about the potential backlash and wanted to ensure that the policy did not create animosity or hinder the integration of communities. This disagreement was reflected in the Constituent Assembly's deliberations over the reservation policy.

3. Role of Religion

Sardar Patel was a staunch advocate of secularism and believed in a clear separation of religion from politics. He was committed to ensuring that India remained a secular state and worked to contain and manage communal tensions, particularly during the partition of India. Ambedkar, while supporting secularism, also had a critical view of religious practices and orthodoxy, particularly within the Hindu caste system. He openly criticized certain aspects of Hinduism and converted to Buddhism with the belief that it offered a more equitable and just way of life.

4. Approach to Social Reform

Sardar Patel, while supportive of social justice, did not take as radical an approach to social reform as Ambedkar did. Ambedkar was a vocal critic of the caste system and advocated for its annihilation, while Patel focused more on integrating marginalized communities within the existing social framework.

5. Political Alliances

In the political arena, Patel was closely associated with the Indian National Congress and was a key figure in the Congress's leadership, while Ambedkar had an independent political career and led the Scheduled Castes Federation. Their different political affiliations sometimes led to policy disagreements and tensions.

It's important to recognize that despite these differences, both Patel and Ambedkar made significant contributions to the nation-building process in India. Their disagreements reflected the diversity of opinions and perspectives in the complex and multifaceted Indian society during a crucial period of its history.

You can also join our WhatsApp group to get premium and selected news of The Mooknayak on WhatsApp. Click here to join the WhatsApp group.

The Mooknayak English - Voice Of The Voiceless